Current Affairs General elections just hours away
Less than twenty-four hours before polling stations open for general elections the two strongest parties on the Czech political scene - the ruling Social Democrats and the opposition Civic Democrats - are running a very tight race. Although it is not clear which of them will be first past the post it is almost certain that neither will win enough votes to set up its own majority government. Coalition and consensus is the name of the game on the Czech political scene and political analysts are already debating the pros and cons of various coalition scenarios.
Jiri Paroubek and Mirek Topolanek, photo: CTK
In a system of proportional representation pact building is a post-election
necessity. And although only five parties are expected to cross the 5%
margin needed to gain seats in parliament the possibilities are
considerable: a grand coalition of the two biggest parties, a majority
coalition government or a minority government with the tacit support of
part of the opposition. In the last decade the Czech Republic has been run
by coalitions with a very slim majority or by a minority government. Such
pacts are in danger of crumbling at a time of crisis - and on occasion
legislation is hard to push through.
As usual all five parties which are expected to make it to Parliament - the Social Democrats, the Civic Democrats, the Communists, the Greens and the Christian Democrats are keeping their options open. However some restrictions are surfacing. If opinion surveys are anything to go by then the Greens and the Christian Democrats are going to be the kingmakers - or power brokers- in these elections. Neither want anything to do with the Communists, who have come third in the last two elections. So it appears that the Greens and Christian Democrats will either swing right or left depending on which of the two big parties is in a position to make a first -or better - offer.
Jiri Paroubek, photo: CTK
However the process of power brokering in such a scenario would not be
easy. The Social Democrats are not on the best of terms with the Christian
Democrats who in recent months have acted more like an opposition party
than a member of the governing coalition. On the other hand the opposition
Civic Democrats are wary of the Greens who have made it clear that they
will not support President Klaus - the founder of the Civic Democratic
Party - in the next presidential elections. And to complicate matters
further, the leader of the Greens is now furious with the leader off the
Social Democrats, accusing him of sowing friction within the Greens and
helping to establish a leftist faction within the party. Political analyst
Vladimira Dvorakova says that although the Green Party clearly has a place
in Czech politics a coalition involving the Greens - would not be easy for
either of the bigger parties:
Mirek Topolanek, photo: CTK
"Any coalition with the Greens is considered very problematic. In
this case it would depend upon how strong the coalition would be. If it
was a tiny majority of 101 or 102 votes - with one or two MPs forming the
majority - then this could be problematic because the Greens who would
make it to Parliament are very individualistic. They are strong
personalities and the party is not very disciplined, not very well
organized. There could be a lot of alternative positions and in a
parliamentary system this really can complicate the decision making
process and the efficiency of the Cabinet."
Despite the possible problems with a party that is new to high politics and not too consolidated and another which has a reputation of wrecking coalition governments - the coalition scenarios involving the Greens and Christian Democrats appear to be the most likely at this point.
President Klaus has signalled that he will not be satisfied with a
minority government - if such a situation can be avoided and a grand
coalition between the Civic and Social Democrats is considered unlikely,
though theoretically possible, because the two party's policy programmes
would make it hard to find common ground. Although the Social Democrats
have not ruled out a minority government supported by the communists -
this would be frowned upon by the public and the President and the Social
Democratic Party's efforts to distance itself from the Communists in
recent days suggests that they would prefer to cooperate with the
Communists at arm's length for some time longer.
So barring some
unprecedented development in terms of voter preferences - the Czech
Republic could be facing another stalemate followed by a fragile coalition
government. For some this is proof that a majority election system might be
preferable to a proportional one. But others, like Vladimira Dvorakova,
highlight the importance of consensus.
"You know in the Czech Republic people are very strongly against compromise, against consensus, they consider it to be something immoral. This is very different from Western countries where the ability to find some compromise and reach consensus is regarded as a basic skill of any good and responsible politician. I think that compromises are also important because they do not polarize society, society is not divided into winners and losers and it helps to integrate society."





